Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Robin Collins's avatar

A good article. Where I would tread carefully is in the critique of the “emergent hostility to tradition”. I am a critic of much tradition because a good proportion of it is outmoded and deserves to be challenged and undermined. We should welcome that ongoing process of modernization — it is quite different from the anti-enlightenment posture of the postmodernists, so we need to distinguish the two. I think your reference here to woke “cherry-picking” implies this distinction.

Expand full comment
Christopher Eastman-Nagle's avatar

Not believing in a deistic account of reality doesn't mean that that account has no value, or that the social and existential wealth it husbands isn't an important component of our individual and collective wealth portfolio., or that our 'account' does not persist long after our deaths in the legacy we leave our descendants. The problem of salvation never disappears. Only the prisms that we look at it through change.

The rise of religious fundamentalism in a decaying world order arises from all sides. Woke fundamentalism is just the latest iteration of the trend, which started to become noticeable after the failure of the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan and the subsequent fall of the Soviet Union.

Everyone is resorting to their bottom lines in the sand and preparing for war, much as we did at the outbreak of the Reformation, 500 years ago, at the beginning of the modern period.

https://www.writing.com/main/view_item/item_id/2205477-Luthers-Last-Laugh-Indulgermania

https://www.writing.com/main/books/item_id/2064958-The-Secular-Fundamentalist

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts