Why has Canada twice been referred to the International Criminal Court on the basis of false claims about Indian residential schools?
Woke Watch Canada is a reader-supported publication. Please consider becoming a paying subscriber or making a one-time or recurring donation to show your support.
By Nina Green
Why has Canada twice been referred to the International Criminal Court on the basis of false claims about Indian residential schools?
The answer is simple.
The ultimate cause is the University of Manitoba's National Student Memorial which falsely claims that it is a list of students who died on the premises of Indian residential schools and students who went missing from Indian residential schools. The University of Manitoba site tells users to:
Click on a region below to see a list of residential schools. Each residential school page contains a list of students who died or went missing at that school.
Those claims by the University of Manitoba are not true.
Firstly, the majority of the 4139 students currently on the University of Manitoba's Student Memorial Register did not die on the premises of an Indian residential school. Most died elsewhere, as established by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission report entitled Missing Children and Unmarked Burials, which in Table 4. Location of residential school deaths, 1867–2000 on page 21 states that only 423 named students died on the premises of an Indian residential school over the course of 133 years, an average of 3 students a year.
Thus, the majority of students did not die on the premises of Indian residential schools. They died elsewhere - in public hospitals or of illness or accidents on their home reserves, accidents which included house fires, drownings, gunshot wounds, vehicle accidents, falling trees, being hit by trains, and other accidental deaths, as established in hundreds of provincial death certificates.
Secondly, none of the students on the University of Manitoba's lists went missing from an Indian residential school. To date, the University of Manitoba has not provided the name of a single Indian residential school student who went missing and whose parents did not know at the time what had happened to their child. Not one. And far from being 'missing', in fact hundreds of provincial death certificates establish that the students were buried on their home reserves by their families and communities.
Based on the University of Manitoba's misleading lists, the media and the federal government uncritically accepted the false claim by the Kamloops Band on 27 May 2021 that the Band had discovered 'the remains of 215 children'. After three years, the Band downgraded that false claim on 18 May 2024 to the claim that it had merely discovered '215 anomalies', which could be anything, and are almost certainly the remains of the 2000 linear feet of trenches of a septic field installed in 1924 to dispose of the school's sewage.
The first referral to the International Criminal Court by a group of 22 lawyers
Only a few days after the Kamloops Band made its false claim, on 3 June 2021 a group of 22 lawyers sent a 14 page complaint to the ICC requesting the Prosecutor to initiate an investigation of a 'mass grave' of Indian residential school students which had been discovered at Kamloops. The claim by the 22 lawyers that a 'mass grave' had been discovered at Kamloops was, of course, false.
The International Criminal Court quickly declined jurisdiction in November 2021, and on 13 September 2022 Dr Chile Eboe-Osuji, former President and Judge of the International Criminal Court, informed Special Interlocutor Kimberly Murray and those present at her National Gathering in Edmonton of the reasons for doing so. As reported by Chief Derek Nepinak, Dr Eboe-Osuji stated unequivocally that:
There is no pathway to the International Criminal Court for the situation of the historical Indian residential school system in Canada.
Dr Eboe-Osuji's presentation has never been made available on the Special Interlocutor's website, and requests to both Kimberly Murray and Dr Eboe-Osuji for a copy of his presentation have gone unanswered.
The second referral to the International Criminal Court by Special Interlocutor Kimberly Murray
Undeterred by the ICC's refusal to accept jurisdiction and the reasons offered by Dr Eboe-Osuji in his presentation to her 13 September 2022 National Gathering, Kimberly Murray pursued the issue on the basis of the University of Manitoba's lists falsely claiming that all the students on its lists died on the premises of specific Indian residential schools or went missing from those schools.
On 29 October 2024, Kimberly Murray delivered her final report to Minister of Justice Arif Virani. However, as she told the Senate Standing Committee on Indigenous Peoples on 27 November 2024, Kimberly Murray also sent her report to the International Criminal Court, requesting Canada's prosecution by the Court.
How the ICC will react to Kimberly Murray's referral of Canada for prosecution is as yet unknown.
Damage to Canada's international reputation
Canada's reputation has been irreparably damaged by these two referrals to the International Criminal Court based on the University of Manitoba's National Student Memorial which falsely claims that it is a list of students who died on the premises of specific residential schools or went missing from those specific schools.
It cannot be reiterated often enough:
(1) that most students whose names are on the University of Manitoba's National Student Memorial did not die on the premises of a residential school;
(2) that most students on the University of Manitoba's National Student Memorial died in public hospitals or of illness and accidents on their home reserves;
(3) that the University of Manitoba has never provided the name of a single student who ever went missing from an Indian residential school whose parents didn't know what happened to their child; and
(4) that the majority of students whose names are on the University of Manitoba's National Student Memorial were buried by their families and communities on their home reserves. Over time, their families and communities have forgotten them, and through neglect of the grave markers, no longer know where in their reserve cemeteries they are buried.
The University of Manitoba's National Student Memorial has misled Canadians and has resulted in two referrals of Canada for prosecution by the International Criminal Court on the basis of false claims about 'mass graves' and 'missing' and 'disappeared' Indian residential school students.
The federal government and the Catholic Church must demand that the University of Manitoba take down its false and misleading National Student Memorial.
Thanks for reading. For more from this author read Did Kimberly Murray write the 94 TRC Calls to Action?
Follow Woke Watch Canada on X - @WokeWatchCanada
Support Woke Watch Canada by upgrading to a paid membership:
Or, by contributing to our Donor Box:
All this because of "The lies and misinformation commission" but never forget that the asshole who started the ball rolling is Blackface himself the prime Turd of Canada. Having divided this country from coast to coast to coast and bankrupted us with all of the lieberal fraud and theft from the taxpayers leaving us overrun with dangerous immigrants from 3rd world countries that all hate our guts. It will take 50 years to recover from what this bastard has done.
The legendary and redoubtable researcher Nina Green states “the University of Manitoba's National Student Memorial has misled Canadians and has resulted in two referrals of Canada for prosecution by es that the International Criminal Court on the basis of false claims about 'mass graves' and 'missing' and 'disappeared' Indian residential school students.” Yet not one politician or political figure in Canada has dared to speak about the false claims. Truth takes a backseat to the self interests of politicians.