Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Hymie Rubenstein's avatar

What is most important of all to do is to compare the findings on this new IRS Records site, nearly all recorded as they occurred, with the six volumes of reports and other findings of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) of Canada, much based on recollections made decades after the last school closed from a sample of former students with an axe to grind or pockets to line.

It is both morally unconscionable and a betrayer of the fundamental norms of Western justice to allow the alleged victims of oppressive behaviour total freedom to subjectively report on the nature of their oppression with little effort made to substantiate their accusations with the testimonies of objective observers intimately familiar with the same facts.

Truth can never be found and justice never serving in this way but this was exactly the way the biased and self-serving investigations of the IRSs operated from begining to end.

Joan's avatar

It's funny how it’s labelled denialism if one seeks to include all Indigenous voices and experiences in the big, complicated picture of the IRS, even while acknowledging that serious harms and abuses did occur. But it’s perfectly acceptable, in fact it’s “correct,” to amplify a certain subset of experiences while excluding, denying or discrediting all others, and that’s NOT considered denialism -- it’s declared to be the truth (as in, “the truth of residential schools” that we all need to educate ourselves on). We can study volumes and read dozens of IRS student memoirs, perhaps more intensively (and extensively) than many Indigenous spokespeople have, and yet the only acceptable conclusion we are allowed to draw (if we are to be considered satisfactorily “educated”) is that every child was harmed, most were abused, many were murdered, and none were benefited in any way.

Congratulations to Nina Green on this impressive and important website.

7 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?